top

A feel for big numbers,
with grains of salt
 On Being Approximate
visualizing big piles

salt
grains

 a thousand in a pinch a million in a cup, a billion in a bathtub, a trillion in a classroom

Counting...
(with a grain of salt, say ±50%)
 a grain of salt One 100 1. some grains ten 101 10. a tiny pile hundred 102 100. a pinch thousand 103 1,000. 1/4 teaspoon ten thousand 104 10,000. tablespoon hundred thousand 105 100,000. 1/2 cup million 106 1,000,000. ten million 107 10,000,000. hundred million 108 100,000,000. a bathtub billion 109 1,000,000,000. ten billion 1010 10,000,000,000. hundred billion 1011 100,000,000,000. a classroom trillion 1012 1,000,000,000,000.

Perhaps this would be better done with sugar, as it tastes better...
With a 1mm grain size, it would be something like:
sugar
grains

 a thousand in 1/4 teaspoon a million in a 2lb box (a few cups), a billion in m3 ("inside of a car"?) a trillion in 103 m3 ("a couple of rooms"?)

With 1/4 billion people (1/4 bathtub of grains) in the US... How much are under 14 years old? Unemployed? How fast is salt being added by birth? Removed by death?
(Lots of stats available...)

With a room filled to the ceiling with a trillion grains, when you open the door and paw at it with cupped hands, how much/fast do you move? With a shovel? A bucket?
(The US budget is a trillion and a half dollars. How much per day? Second? How much is Medicare? Social security? Education? Space?)

Salt is fascinating stuff. Roman legions were payed in it, cities taxed, evaporating salt-water for it was a crime. Politics, rebellions, required for life, preservation of food. Perhaps someone has done a web page...

 A View from the Back of the Envelope Comments encouraged. - Mitchell N Charity

```History:
2000-Oct-17  Repointed "stats" link to something similar that works.  Thanks to a reader.
1997.May     Created.
```

```The back of my envelope...

I'm using "Morton Salt" (table salt).
First, some quick and dirty work...
The grains measure about 1/2 mm,
which gives 20/cm  8000/cm3  8 x 109/m3  1010/m3
Its box is a cylinder 6 x 10-4 m3 (8cm d, 12cm h),
and masses 0.737 kg,
so thats a density of about 1.2 kg/m3 (1.2 g/cm3).
So 10-10 kg/grain, and 5 x 106 grains in the box.

More carefully measuring the grains,
I get 0.5 +- 0.05 (about 1 grain uncertainty in 5mm).
Upping the sample to 10mm didnt seem to help narrow the uncertainty
(due to grain size variations).
With this big an uncertainty, I'm not going to worry about how
tighly packed the grains are.
thus
20/cm (+-2)   6000 to 11000 /cm3  0.6 to 1.1  × 1010
so 1010 (+10%-40% for measurement uncertainty)
which gives worst-case percent errors of +70% and -10%.
So, probably an overestimate, possibly by a factor of 2, but not
much of an underestimate.

So...
grains/m3 1010 × 0.6 to 1.1
kg/grain 10-10 × 1 to 2
grains/kg 1010 × 0.5 to 1

Ok, what are some accessible volumes.
teaspoon   4.9x10-6 m3
tablespoon 1.5x10-5 m3
cup 2.4x10-4 m3
gallonUS liquid 3.8x10-3 m3
foot3 0.028 m3
bathtub ~0.2 m3 (~8 ft3)
classroom ~200 m3 (10x8x2.5 m)

So
teaspoon 3 to 6 × 104, or
tablespoon 0.9 to 2 × 105
cup 1 to 3 × 106
bathtub 1 to 2 × 109
classroom 1 to 2 × 1012

Ok.  Time for a reality check.
A big pinch looks about 103 grains
(by dividing it in half a couple of times and then counting).
So a 1/4 teaspoon seems 104 or two.
Which sortof fits.
(_This_ time it fits.  The first time it didn't.
Turned out I had mangled the  object vs # grains  paragraph.
And in tracing it down, I would have done a lot better to
let the numbers lead me, rather than having an emotional stake
in their fitting.  A lesson.)

I could do this more carefully, but for now...

Call it
a 1/4 teaspoon for 104
a tablespoon for 105
a 1/2 cup for 108
a bathub for 109
a classroom for 1012.
```

A quick hack of a graph...
Grain size (on the diagonals) vs volume & how many grains

I should address the non-linear error "feel". 50% seems a bigger deal for big numbers than for small ones.